Does fear of criticism stop you posting?

One of the things that can hold therapists back from using social media to reach clients is the fear of criticism.  Therapists hesitate to post on social media or spend a lot of time writing and re-writing posts to avoid negative comments.

They’re concerned that other therapists may disagree with them, that they could be accused of being unethical, or simply that they’ll be misunderstood. Any of these possibilities might make them think twice before posting.

And indeed, their concerns might have a good foundation because they’ve read social media comments and seen people judged and criticised online. Sometimes it feels safer to keep quiet.

However, the opinions we see on social media don’t necessarily represent what most people think. Understanding this could help us feel more confident about posting.

This is the subject of the Good Enough Counsellors podcast: Coping with Negative Comments on Social Media. You can listen to the full episode below:

If you would like to subscribe to the podcast, click here.

Can you trust the comments you read on social media?

Two experiences have recently made me question what I see online.

Joe Dunthorne’s experience

The first was reading an article by a writer, Joe Dunthorne, in The Guardian.

Joe described how he receives daily emails from “fans” offering to recommend his books to others. While he suspects these are scams, he decided to follow one offer up where a woman offered to increase his readership in the Berlin Book Club on the payment of $500.

He said he’d only pay by delivering the money and asked for an address.  When this was supplied, it was an address in Manila.  Joe speculated that it was nothing to do with Berlin, and everything to do with an online scam.

He described raids on scam farms in the Philippines, where people may be coerced or employed into multiple online identities.  And that made me wonder how much we really know about the people behind online accounts.

International Pronouns Day

The second experience was more personal to me. I was moderating a trans-positive page about International Pronouns Day when it went viral at midnight, BST.

There were more than 100 comments by breakfast the next day, and Meta reported that 20% of the comments originated in the Philippines.

Considering the post was aimed at a UK audience, I questioned whether these comments were genuine and honestly interested in a trans page.

There is no proof that either of these situations came from troll farms but it was interesting to read Joe describe what such farms are like and where many are located 

Why do some social media posts attract so many negative comments?

It’s helpful to remember that on a free platform, revenue is earned through adverts.  It’s therefore profitable for platforms to keep people engaged, the longer the better so that they can view more adverts.

Social media platforms do this in the following ways:

  • Give posts that are engaging readers more prominence in the feed, with the number of comments being one indicator of engagement
  • Distribute engaging posts to non-followers

Posts that attract strong opinions are the ones that are likely to attract comments, and these are often the ones that receive wide distribution.  They’re also the ones that you’re more likely to see because they’re popular.

However, this can give you a distorted picture of what people are really thinking:

  • First, because we don’t always know who is behind the comments or what motivates them, and 
  • Second, because many people will not join the comments because of the fear of attracting negative responses.

Why do negative comments affect us so much?

We can receive ten lovely comments and still find ourselves dwelling on the one negative one.

We’re naturally attuned to notice danger.  Negative comments on social media can represent the modern day equivalent of being rejected by our tribe.  Criticism can lead to us feeling unsafe and comments hurt as a result.

In my experience, online criticism leads to an instant heartsink and I have to take time to allow my nervous system to settle and return to my calm self.  Often I’ll wait 24 hours before responding to a comment in order to give that process time.

Particularly if you’re someone who has been on the receiving end of gaslighting or bullying, other people’s strongly stated opinions can lead to self-doubt.  You wonder if they’re right and there’s something you’ve missed.

And while there’s room for you to reflect on whether criticism is valid, it is also helpful to seek support from people who you really trust and who believe in you. This can help you find balance again.

Are the people commenting likely to be your clients?

Imagine that you’ve written a post about people-pleasing and how hard it is to say no.

A commentator replies that it’s quite simple really, people “just need to stand up for themselves”.

But you’re not trying to reach confident people who can set boundaries easily.  You’re writing for someone who feels guilty saying no, finds boundaries hard and who might find counselling helpful.

Remember, the person who you want to help might not be the person commenting. They still need to hear your words.

I’ve found this to be true of people who join Therapy Growth Group.  They’re often people who have been quietly reading my posts in the background and when they’re ready, they join the group.

How can therapists cope with negative social media comments?

So if you’re criticised on social media, what steps can you take?

  1. Don’t respond immediately when you’re upset.  Give yourself some time.
  2. If it’s a comment on your own post, you may be able to “hide” the comment while you decide whether or not to respond. Check how hiding comments works on the platform you’re using.
  3. Ask yourself: who is leaving the comment?  Is it someone you want to engage with, such as a potential client?  Or, is it a “drive-by critic”?
  4. Be honest, is the criticism valid?  Have they identified something unethical, inaccurate or potentially hurtful?  Being aware of their identity can help you decide how much weight you give their comment
  5. If you’re upset it can help to talk it through with someone you trust.  A peer, supervisor, friend or family member.
  6. You can decide whether you want to respond, to hide or moderate the comment.  Remind yourself that you are not obligated to reply.
  7. In your responses, be mindful of counselling ethics.  Does your reply match ethical principles?  This article says more about the BACP Ethical Framework and using Facebook.

It’s helpful to remember that you don’t have to persuade everyone to agree with you.  You can agree to differ. Acknowledge that you’re trying to reach the people you can help, not people who don’t like what you have to say.

And it’s helpful to remind yourself that there are many people who do benefit from what you do.  

Finding the confidence to post anyway

Focus on the people you want to help

Imagining their situation can help you find the courage to want to speak to them. And by producing content that is relevant to them you’re more likely to reach them.

Check your post

Before posting, ask yourself if the post is ethical, respectful and accurate. If you’re worried about self-disclosure, you may find this article helpful

Accept your limitations

You cannot control how other people interpret your post. Your responsibility is to check it, as above. You are not responsible for other people’s reactions.  However, if they are responding on your page, you can take responsibility for the conversations you want there and remove comments if necessary.

Give yourself permission to publish

Don’t give people who are never going to become your clients the power to stop you reaching the ones who will.

Ready to be a little braver?

If fear of criticism or getting things wrong is holding you back from being more visible and you need encouragement to reach out to people, Josephine’s Dream Builder membership has monthly teaching and practical resources to help. Take the next steps towards the things you’d love to achieve.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should counsellors respond to negative comments on social media?

Bear in mind that it’s important to consider your professional ethics, boundaries and client confidentiality. Will answering a comment be helpful? Will it lead to arguments that do not conform to ethical principles? Remember that social media is a public forum and there will be many others reading your response apart from the commentator.

Can I delete negative comments from my counselling Facebook page?

Your Facebook page is your space to moderate and that means you can choose whether or not to delete comments. You decide what is appropriate and what is abusive.  You may also want to consider the feelings of other people who may be reading the comments section.  

How can I feel more confident in posting about my counselling practice?

It helps to focus on your intended audience and what they need to hear.  When someone disagrees, remember that they may not be the type of person you are trying to reach.  You can respect their right to express their opinion but that doesn’t have to stop you expressing yours.

Enjoyed this article?

Join thousands of therapists who receive my weekly email every Thursday.

You’ll receive practical marketing ideas, new podcast episodes and lessons learned from years of helping counsellors attract clients and grow their private practice.

Click here to join us.